Friday, October 12, 2007

Conversation with a visitor

Religious situation in America is very different from that of other countries. Almost all people believe in Christianity. Almost all people in America are Protestants. But the problem is there are tens of millions of denominations among American Protestants. Episcopal, Presbyterian, Evangelicals, Baptists, Anglican, Mormon, etc. It is somehow taken for granted that all people believe in God, Christianity in America. Which denomination that matters.

You see in a country virtually all people believe in Christianity, people tend to believe in Christianity formally, not substantially. Some need to pretend to believe in God because only somebody next to them supposedly believe in God. I must say some people just pretend to believe in God as a pose.

Jehovah's Witnesses were different among those might be pretending to believe in God as a posture.

Situation here in Japan is very different from that in America. Usually I found almost all Christians here regardless of their denominations are very religious and faithful people. Many Jehovah's Witnesses are true Christians. I agree, but I regret to say that some Jehovah's Witnesses are not. At the same time many Catholic believers, Protestants are true Christians. Again some Catholic, Protestants are not.

You often say there's only one God's earthly organisation, though you don't clearly say which is so. Also you mention lots of times about Apostasy. But what is important is not an organisation. It is very beneficial to learn and keep in touch with organisation as long as it helps strengthen your faith. Most important thing is your relationship to God, not organisation.

Now as to New World Translation. This translation was thought to be the work by one man with the help of other four members of committee in Watch Tower. In other major translations more than 100 scholars involved in the work of translation in order not to be biased in a particular idea. Important thing is Bible is a word of God and this book was written in very old times in ancient Hebrew and ancient Greek. We need some interpretation for that reason. Ancient language must be very different from current language. Of course English is very different form Hebrew and Greek in the first place. So what we need to know is what message God really tried to send us humans. All translation of Bible are a result of how we interpret it from original text. Important thing is what God really wanted to send us, not merely what is written. There are many literal expressions as well as figurative expressions. Prophecy is basically figurative. We need to look into what was His real intention.


It is very acceptable for us to use New World Translation in our daily study, but if we felt some questions as to what really God wanted to say, it is strongly recommended to refer to other version of Bible as well as what original language meant.

You don't salute national flag or sing national anthem. You don't accept transfusion. I think national flag, anthem, transfusion have nothing to do with right or wrong. What matters is whether you feel it sinful or not. Jehovah's Witnesses usually feel those conducts violate God's command. Therefore you ought not to do them. Otherwise those have nothing to do with your faith.

As to God's name. I am not sure whether God has a name though your supreme God, Almighty God is called Jehovah by Jehovah's Witnesses. But if some one who has different faith calls his God in different names like Deus in Catholicism, you ought to admit their God is the same as your God. God Himself is the same, but how to call Him that differs.

These are the impressions that I had through conversations with Sister. 

Acceptance & tolerance. Most important factor in religion.


5 comments:

  1. G-D BLESS AMERICA UNiREAL BEAUTIFUL

    HOME OF THE BRAVE LAND OF THE FREE ... ALL AMERICAN PATHFINDER PEACeMAKER ... AFFILIATE "LINK SHARE" PATRIOT PEACeKEEPING PIONEERS

    WeARE ONeNATION iNDIVISIBLE ... ALLforONE "UNITED WE STAND" ONEforALL

    http://A2zDAWAAH.Multiply.com


    BeLIEVE iT ORnot ... WHAT YOU DO ACTUALLY ... FIGURATIVELY LITERALLY VIRTUALLY MORE THAN ONE PROFESSES OR SAYS ... iN OTHER WORDS "iT iS WHAT iT iS" ONES ACTIONS SPEAK LOUDER THAN ONES VERBAL EXPRESSIONS OR MERE WORDS ... FAITH WITHOUT WORKS ADDS UP or COUNTS for nothing

    excuses ARE TRUELY ... TRUTHFULLY useless

    THERE iS WHAT iT iS ONLY DO & DOnot

    aREAL "HINT" TOo THE WISE iS SUFFICIENT

    aREAL fool and MONEY ARE SOoN DEPARTED

    SILENCE iS GOLDEN ... TALK iS CHEAP

    the wages of sin ARE ONES OWN death & self destruction

    waste not WANTnot ... haste MAKES waste

    so many people today ... professing to be this saying they are that
    lying & preaching about being Muslims or Christ Like Christians
    who by their own actions are none of what or who they say they are
    cheating life self destructively killing .... deceitfully murdering stealing from one another
    all in the name of their material idols or false superstitious gods of doom & gloom
    G-D ALMIGHTY HELP THOSE WHO GOSPEL TRUTHFULLY PROFESS
    SAYING THEY ARE THeREAL JEWS or ANCIENT HEBREWS

    they are all indicted by their own arrogant beastlike bloodsucking fearing & smearing
    artificial imitation superficial religious ways of preying on each other endlessly selfishly
    hastily chasing after that which eludes them fantazing about the glitter of fools gold
    indulging wastefully in their own self grandisement ... buying & spending lavishly

    CARING nothing ABOUT BEING "HONEST TOoGOoD" DOING WHATS RIGHT
    ACTING LIKE THEY OWN PLANET EARTH ... they can neither create nor destroy
    TODAY iS WHAT iT iS aREAL TIME FUTURE REVELATION RETRIBUTION
    AWAKENING OF WHAT iS TOo COME TOo THOSE PAST GENERATIONS
    WHO NOW REAP "THeREAL KARMA" THEY TRUTHFULLY SOW

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm finding it hard to follow your style of writing. I'm also not sure what you're trying to say from the perspective of a sceptical outsider.

    What of atheists and (say) pantheists like myself?

    If you're trying to say that there should be a single identity of faith, is that an advance for a state? More likely the compromise reached would then be forced upon everyone. Far better, as Mer Cedo is saying, we would all do well to become more moderate, if we value peace above the fight to perpetuate a particular religious faith.

    If there is a God, he would surely be happiest if we stopped fighting one another...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I have studied with Jehovah's Witnesses, and I respect their sincerity - without sharing their faith.

    The New World translation is somewhat more interpreted than need be; or to put it in another way: it's filled with errors. This goes for the New Testament which I can check since I read Greek; I'm not competent to criticize the translation from Hebrew, really.

    ReplyDelete
  4. New World Translation is the result of their interpretation of Bible. It is Ok as long as they use it in their study circle. If they claimed their Bible is the only right interpretation, they would face some friction. They were using King James, American Standard Bible before and still they use in pamphlet for the non member. They are excellent people if they are tolerant to other Christians, if they accept other point of view within Christian community.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well, they don't accept other points of view in the sense that they are willing to consider them as true, but they don't force or persecute other people. They accept everyone's right to choose for him/herself, and for this I like and respect them.

    ReplyDelete